DAVID BRUCE COLLINS: AUTHOR, ACTIVIST, UBERISTA
  • Index
  • Blog
  • Biography
  • Writing
    • Novels in Print
    • Eastern Daylight (1997) >
      • Eastern Daylight: April
      • Eastern Daylight: May
      • Eastern Daylight: June
      • Eastern Daylight: July
      • Eastern Daylight: August
      • Eastern Daylight: September
      • Eastern Daylight: October
    • Bite-Size Hungarian
    • Latin for the End of the World
  • Politics
    • Life As a Green
    • Ten Key Values of GPUS (English)
    • Issues for 2020
  • Web Links

DBC Sez...

Single-Payer/Universal Health Care Experiences, Part I

5/7/2017

 
Picture
The following is adapted from a Facebook link advocating single-payer health care that I posted last Friday. My motivation in posting it derives from several threads in which a friend, whose views I respect but with whom I frequently disagree, has expressed his opposition.

In asking friends to comment with their direct experiences with national health systems, my original hypothesis was that respondents would gush about how wonderful these systems are—not necessarily ideal, but a great improvement over the profit-driven model found in the US. My guess came close: There were more negatives than I'd envisioned, but most comments were favorable overall toward single-payer and similar systems.

General consensus, among those who have experienced it directly and the mostly American bunch whose friends and relatives have lived under it, is that the competence of those administering the system is an important factor. There are some not-so-good single-payer systems in existence, and they don't always fix the problems of capitalist health care immediately. Those stories of ridiculous waiting times in Canada may be somewhat exaggerated, but such instances do occur. The UK's National Health Service had problems in the early stages, but the people running that system have learned from earlier mistakes and put those lessons in to practice.

I'm still waiting for some respondents to reply as to whether they will permit me to repost their comments here, so this should be Part I of two.

*****

Original Post
I have a friend with libertarian sympathies whose reaction to any suggestion of single-payer health care is one of dread. He comments with links on my threads about the horrors of single-payer health care: patients & families losing control over their own medical destiny, patients who die waiting for promised treatment, etc.

This post is NOT—repeat NOT—an invitation to slag my friend, or libertarianism with a capital or lowercase L. So don't. That shit will be deleted with all due haste.

Instead, I'd like to see stories of experiences with health care in nations with single-payer or hybrid systems, positive or negative. I invite the following to address the issue.

Chris in the UK
I will relate my most recent experience with our UK NHS, which is easily the most serious medical experience I have had to date.

In June 2016 I suddenly began to experience episodes of near-fainting and occasional visual disturbances. These often occu
rred while driving, so I was forced to virtually give up driving for several months. During this period I had 4 or 5 consultations with General Practitioners, 3 blood tests, an ambulatory blood pressure monitor fitted for a day, an ambulatory heart monitor fitted for a week, two ECGs, an echocardiogram, an MRI of my brain, a consultation with an ENT specialist, two consultations with a cardiologist, a consultation with a neurologist, a tilt test carried out by a nurse specialist, and a subcutaneous heart monitor inserted in my chest (which I still have 3 months later). All of this was free.

The doctors were all pretty obviously baffled by my symptoms, but eventually it was the tilt test and accompanying consultation with the nurse specialist that provided the diagnosis – reflex vasovagal syncope, caused (would you believe) by my drinking too much caffeine. I now drink no caffeine, have no symptoms, and am driving normally.

Relevant points are:
- the treatment was free under the NHS
- I got a diagnosis
- the diagnosis took about 7 months.

What seems to have prevented the doctors quickly arriving at the correct diagnosis was that syncope normally involves actual fainting and happens mainly to people standing up, whereas mine did not involve actual fainting and occurred mostly when I was sitting down. Also there were odd visual symptoms which with hindsight were perhaps a distraction. Would doctors elsewhere in the world have been cleverer, or would a different healthcare system have allowed them to get there quicker? I have no way of knowing.

Tim, formerly in Canada
In Canada, several years ago, my ex-wife
- had a dickens of a time finding a GP in Manitoba; most female GPs had patient waiting lists, and she only managed to get on a female GP's rolls because her sister was already a patient
- was sent to an ortho
pedic specialist by her GP, who determined that yes, there was an operable knee problem & scheduled an outpatient surgery
- ...for about six months away, as nothing else was available sooner
- which, combined with her weight and work environment, resulted in her needing a similar surgery for her other knee well before she was able to receive treatment for the first

In Canada, several years ago, I
- went to a walk-in clinic for a throat issue, saw a doctor within 15 minutes, was prescribed antibiotics in 20, showed them my SIN card, and walked across the corner to the drugstore to buy my generics

In Canada, several years ago, my ex-wife's buddy
- was concussed playing hockey
- was accompanied to the nearest emergency room by us
- sat with us for ~4 hours before seeing a doctor and receiving the standard cautions and temporary prohibitions

The speed with which one receives care really depends on the situation, but can be pretty poor if one needs a surgical procedure. There's still the enormous upside of the surgeries not bankrupting our "college student and unskilled worker" household; not having those surgeries sooner made my ex-wife unable to work, putting additional stress on our finances.

It's a mixed bag; it's not magical. It does save families from being swamped by gigantic debts...if one of the families' breadwinners isn't on a waiting list.

Dan in Germany
Germany doesn't have a single payer system but everyone must have some form of health insurance. The big difference is that many insurance companies, like mine, are non profit organizations. I have immediate access to my general practitioner, or Hausarzt, and can make appointments with any specialist I choose. My total health care expenses in 2016 were 482 euro, less than most Americans pay each month.
Christine, who grew up partly in Norway and Japan
I have lived and traveled in countries with national health care systems. I and family members received excellent care at no cost. Nothing but good experiences!
Jorge, formerly in Mexico (definitely not single-payer)
My brother fell of the side of a mountain hiking in Mexico. This is Mexico so he got fired since he could not go to work. No work, no money, no insurance. He is alive. He did not have to pay anything.
Could the service be a lot better? YES. 
Is he alive and not broke because of medical bills? YES.

Comments are closed.

    Blogging Sporadically since 2014

    Here you will find political campaign-related entries, as well as some about my literature, Houston underground arts, peace & justice, urban cycling, soccer, alt-religion, and other topics.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    2018
    Abby Martin
    Abortion Laws
    ACORN
    Affordable Care Act
    Ahmad Hassan
    Air Alliance Houston
    Ajamu Baraka
    Alabama
    Alexandria Ocasio Cortez
    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
    Al Gore
    Amanda Palmer
    Amazon
    Angela Walker
    Angie Schmitt
    ANM 2020
    Annual Meeting
    Approval Voting
    Art Car Parade
    Astroworld
    Ballot Access
    Bernie Sanders
    Beto O'Rourke
    BikeHouston
    Binary Thinking
    Black Agenda Report
    #BlackLivesMatter
    Bloomsday
    B&N
    Book Review
    Borders
    Brains And Eggs
    Breast Cancer
    Brody Mulligan
    Burning Man
    Bylaws
    Caitlin Johnstone
    Caleb Alexander
    Campaign
    Campaign 2018
    Candidates' Forum
    Candidate Workshop
    Captcha
    Catastrophic Theatre
    Cenk Uygur
    Censorship
    Chelsea Manning
    Cheri Honkala
    Chicago
    Choir
    Chris Hedges
    Chris Tomlinson
    Chuck Kuffner
    City Council
    Climate Change
    Climate March
    Climate Strike
    CODEPINK
    Colin Kaepernick
    Convention
    Corporatocracy
    County Clerk
    County Convention
    County Judge
    Cover Design
    COVID 19
    COVID-19
    Cycling
    Dallas Morning News
    Dan Monahan
    Dario Hunter
    Darryl Cherney
    David Cobb
    David Rovics
    Death By Cop
    Death Penalty
    Debates
    Deep State
    Delilah For Texas
    #DemEnter
    #DemExit
    Demexit
    Democrat Primary
    Depression
    Detroit 2020
    Dichotomism
    Dick Dowling
    Disaffiliation
    District Conventions
    Donald Trump
    #DownticketGreens
    DSA
    Duopoly
    Dwight Boykins
    Early Voting
    Earth Day
    Earthworm
    Eastern Daylight
    Ecological Wisdom
    Economic Justice
    Ed Emmett
    Edie
    Egberto WIllies
    Eleanor Goldfield
    Election 2015
    Election 2016
    Election 2017
    Election 2018
    Election 2019
    Election 2020
    Election 2022
    Electoral College
    Elvis Costello
    Emancipation Park
    Emily Sanchez
    Emily Sanchez
    Endorsements
    Energy
    Environment
    Erika Martinez
    Extinction Rebellion
    Fascism
    Fauxcialism
    Fiction
    Film Review
    For The People Act
    Fourth Turning
    Francesca Fiorentini
    Fremont Solstice Parade
    Full Frontal
    Fundraising
    Gary Johnson
    Gary Stuard
    George Floyd
    George HW Bush
    George Lakoff
    George Reiter
    Georgia
    Gerrymandering
    Glenn Greenwald
    GPTX
    Gray Matters
    Green Convention
    #GreenEnter
    Green Maps
    Green New Deal
    Green Party
    Green Party Houston
    Greenwatch TV
    Gun Violence
    Hallucinogens
    Hal Ridley Jr.
    Harris County
    Harry Hamid
    HAUS
    HAUS Project
    HB 2504
    HCGP
    Higher Education
    Hillary Clinton
    HMS
    Homelessness
    Houston
    Houston Area Progressives
    Houston Astros
    Houston Chronicle
    Houston Dash
    Houston Dynamo
    Houston Fringe Festival
    Houston Press
    Howie Hawkins
    Hurricane Harvey
    Identity Politics
    Immigration
    Instant Runoff Voting
    Insurrection At The Capitol
    International Affairs
    Inverted Totalitarianism
    Iran
    Ireland
    IRV
    IUniverse
    James Joyce
    Janis RIchards
    Jennifer Mathieu
    Jesse Ventura
    Jill Stein
    Jimmy Dore
    Jonathan Franzen
    Jordan Chariton
    JosH Darr
    Julian Assange
    Juneteenth
    Justice
    Kenneth Kendrick
    Kenneth Mejia
    Kent Mesplay
    Keystone XL
    Key Values
    KPFT
    Krystal Ball
    Laredo
    Last Week Tonight
    Late Stage Capitalism
    Late-Stage Capitalism
    League Of Women Voters
    Lee Camp
    Legal Challenge
    Libertarian Party
    Lina Hidalgo
    Lisa Savage
    Local Democracy
    Mail-In Ballots
    Maine
    Maps Project
    #MarchForOurLives
    March For Science
    March On The Pentagon
    Marc Lamont Hill
    Margaret Flowers
    Marijuana
    Martina Salinas
    Mass Shootings
    Matching Funds
    Mayor
    MD Anderson Cancer Center
    Media
    Medicare For All
    Mental Health
    Metro
    Michael Moore
    Michael Pollan
    MJ Hegar
    Movement For A People's Party
    Mudslinging
    Music
    Naomi Klein
    NationBuilder
    Net Neutrality
    New Orleans
    New Zealand
    Nick Cooper
    NORML
    North Carolina
    Our Revolution
    Outlander
    Outreach
    Overdevelopment
    Pacifica
    Parkland FL
    Partisan Realignment
    Paul Ingmundson
    PDiddie
    Peace
    Pennsylvania
    People's Party Convention
    Platform
    Plutocracy
    PNC
    Police
    Police Brutality
    Politics Done Right
    Polls
    Poor People's Campaign
    Poverty
    Progressivism
    Proofreading
    ProPublica
    Puerto Rico
    Radicalism
    Ranked Choice Voting
    Ray Hill
    Recount 2016
    Remington Alessi
    #Resistance
    Rev. Barber
    Revolution
    Right-wing Terrorism
    Rosa Clemente
    Russiagate
    Samantha Bee
    San Antonio
    SB 2093
    School Shootings
    Scotland
    Scottish National Party
    Scott McLarty
    Sema Hernandez
    Sheila Jackson Lee
    Single Payer
    SKCM Curry
    Smart Growth
    Socialism
    Socialist Alternative
    Spoiler Effect
    Straight Party Voting
    Strauss & Howe
    Sunrise Movement
    Sylvester Turner
    Syria
    Tax Policy
    Ted Cruz
    Texas House
    Texas Leftist
    Texas Legislature
    Texas Progressive
    Texas Public Radio
    Texas Supreme Court
    Texoblogosphere
    Texpatriate
    The Intercept
    The North Star
    Third Parties
    Thom Hartmann
    Traffic
    Transit
    Transportation
    Trans Rights
    Travel
    Treason
    Trump Derangement Syndrome
    Tulsi Gabbard
    Turnout
    Ulysses
    Unitarian Universalism
    Urbanism
    US Senate
    UU
    Valarie Kaur
    Van Cliburn
    Vanessa Edwards Foster
    Vanessa Guillén
    Venezuela
    Vish
    Vision Zero
    War On Drugs
    Website
    Women's March On Pentagon
    World Beyond War
    World Cup
    World Naked Bike Ride
    Zeitgeist Movement
    Zendik

    Archives

    April 2023
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Index
  • Blog
  • Biography
  • Writing
    • Novels in Print
    • Eastern Daylight (1997) >
      • Eastern Daylight: April
      • Eastern Daylight: May
      • Eastern Daylight: June
      • Eastern Daylight: July
      • Eastern Daylight: August
      • Eastern Daylight: September
      • Eastern Daylight: October
    • Bite-Size Hungarian
    • Latin for the End of the World
  • Politics
    • Life As a Green
    • Ten Key Values of GPUS (English)
    • Issues for 2020
  • Web Links